Market Note, January 2026

Gold's Identity Crisis as an Alternative

Performance
Summary
20252026 YTDLast 3 Year
(Cumulative)
Last 3 Years
(Annualized)
2010 - 2023
(Cumulative)
2010 - 2023
(Annualized)
S&P 500 Index16.4%1.9%81.7%22.0%367.7%12.6%
Gold Index142.6%29.5%281.0%56.1%(19.9%)(1.7%)

Gold has become a prominent topic among relationship managers, private bankers, and ultimately retail traders, funneling into the asset class with the popular “tsunami” style trading approach as Average Daily Trading Volumes (ADTV) across the market has increased by 80% over the past 24-36 months. This surge in activity has driven renewed discussion around the role of Gold allocations within portfolios. In this note, I analyze Gold’s performance and correlation over the last 15-year period, challenging whether Gold should continue to be classified as an Alternative.

For much of its history, Gold’s price movements have exhibited return characteristics similar to cash and short-duration secured credit, providing both idiosyncratic risk protection and broader downside resilience. Across multiple market cycles and unpredictable events since 2010 - including periods of exuberance, corrections, and market stress - Gold has consistently demonstrated stable, defensive behavior. supporting it's classification as an 'Alternative'. In other words, Gold has been the modern-day 'devil child' - an asset class audacious enough to provide predictability in a market obsessed with return chasing and inflated ROI expectations.

Exhibit 1 analyzes the growth of a hypothetical $1,000 investment in Gold from 2010-2026. The focal point of the analysis is the clear divergence in convexity and price behavior relative to the S&P 500. The most notable point-in-time is the recent three-year period (highlighted in gradient), during which Gold’s behavior diverges materially from its historical presence. Recent behavior reflects 'factor-styles' typically foreign to Alternative sleeves: rising correlation to risk assets, heightened short-term volatility, and surges in speculative trading activity - as evidenced by increased retail participation and sharply higher ADTV's.

Growth of $1,000 Investment: S&P 500 vs. Gold (2010–2026)

Exhibit 1
  • S&P 500 Index
  • S&P Gold Index
-1,0002,0003,0004,0005,0006,000
100% of Gold’s cumulative 15-year gains have occurred after March 2025.
Dec 31, 2010S&P 500 Index$1,000S&P Gold Index$1,000Mar 31, 2011S&P 500 Index$1,054S&P Gold Index$945Quarter: S&P / Gold5.4% / -5.5%Jun 30, 2011S&P 500 Index$1,050S&P Gold Index$868Quarter: S&P / Gold-0.4% / -8.2%Sep 30, 2011S&P 500 Index$900S&P Gold Index$939Quarter: S&P / Gold-14.3% / 8.1%Dec 30, 2011S&P 500 Index$1,000S&P Gold Index$857Quarter: S&P / Gold11.2% / -8.7%Mar 30, 2012S&P 500 Index$1,120S&P Gold Index$800Quarter: S&P / Gold12.0% / -6.7%Jun 29, 2012S&P 500 Index$1,083S&P Gold Index$724Quarter: S&P / Gold-3.3% / -9.5%Sep 28, 2012S&P 500 Index$1,146S&P Gold Index$830Quarter: S&P / Gold5.8% / 14.8%Dec 31, 2012S&P 500 Index$1,134S&P Gold Index$720Quarter: S&P / Gold-1.0% / -13.2%Mar 28, 2013S&P 500 Index$1,248S&P Gold Index$606Quarter: S&P / Gold10.0% / -15.9%Jun 28, 2013S&P 500 Index$1,277S&P Gold Index$405Quarter: S&P / Gold2.4% / -33.1%Sep 30, 2013S&P 500 Index$1,337S&P Gold Index$419Quarter: S&P / Gold4.7% / 3.3%Dec 31, 2013S&P 500 Index$1,470S&P Gold Index$372Quarter: S&P / Gold9.9% / -11.1%Mar 31, 2014S&P 500 Index$1,489S&P Gold Index$430Quarter: S&P / Gold1.3% / 15.6%Jun 30, 2014S&P 500 Index$1,559S&P Gold Index$467Quarter: S&P / Gold4.7% / 8.7%Sep 30, 2014S&P 500 Index$1,568S&P Gold Index$396Quarter: S&P / Gold0.6% / -15.3%Dec 31, 2014S&P 500 Index$1,637S&P Gold Index$347Quarter: S&P / Gold4.4% / -12.5%Mar 31, 2015S&P 500 Index$1,644S&P Gold Index$371Quarter: S&P / Gold0.4% / 7.2%Jun 30, 2015S&P 500 Index$1,640S&P Gold Index$358Quarter: S&P / Gold-0.2% / -3.5%Sep 30, 2015S&P 500 Index$1,527S&P Gold Index$295Quarter: S&P / Gold-6.9% / -17.6%Dec 31, 2015S&P 500 Index$1,625S&P Gold Index$308Quarter: S&P / Gold6.5% / 4.3%Mar 31, 2016S&P 500 Index$1,638S&P Gold Index$433Quarter: S&P / Gold0.8% / 40.7%Jun 30, 2016S&P 500 Index$1,669S&P Gold Index$601Quarter: S&P / Gold1.9% / 38.6%Sep 30, 2016S&P 500 Index$1,724S&P Gold Index$564Quarter: S&P / Gold3.3% / -6.1%Dec 30, 2016S&P 500 Index$1,780S&P Gold Index$462Quarter: S&P / Gold3.3% / -18.1%Mar 31, 2017S&P 500 Index$1,879S&P Gold Index$494Quarter: S&P / Gold5.5% / 6.9%Jun 30, 2017S&P 500 Index$1,927S&P Gold Index$463Quarter: S&P / Gold2.6% / -6.1%Sep 29, 2017S&P 500 Index$2,003S&P Gold Index$467Quarter: S&P / Gold4.0% / 0.7%Dec 29, 2017S&P 500 Index$2,126S&P Gold Index$465Quarter: S&P / Gold6.1% / -0.4%Mar 29, 2018S&P 500 Index$2,100S&P Gold Index$444Quarter: S&P / Gold-1.2% / -4.5%Jun 29, 2018S&P 500 Index$2,161S&P Gold Index$455Quarter: S&P / Gold2.9% / 2.7%Sep 28, 2018S&P 500 Index$2,317S&P Gold Index$368Quarter: S&P / Gold7.2% / -19.3%Dec 31, 2018S&P 500 Index$1,993S&P Gold Index$444Quarter: S&P / Gold-14.0% / 20.8%Mar 29, 2019S&P 500 Index$2,254S&P Gold Index$464Quarter: S&P / Gold13.1% / 4.6%Jun 28, 2019S&P 500 Index$2,339S&P Gold Index$524Quarter: S&P / Gold3.8% / 12.9%Sep 30, 2019S&P 500 Index$2,367S&P Gold Index$560Quarter: S&P / Gold1.2% / 6.8%Dec 31, 2019S&P 500 Index$2,569S&P Gold Index$621Quarter: S&P / Gold8.5% / 10.9%Mar 31, 2020S&P 500 Index$2,055S&P Gold Index$560Quarter: S&P / Gold-20.0% / -9.8%Jun 30, 2020S&P 500 Index$2,465S&P Gold Index$822Quarter: S&P / Gold20.0% / 46.8%Sep 30, 2020S&P 500 Index$2,674S&P Gold Index$866Quarter: S&P / Gold8.5% / 5.3%Dec 31, 2020S&P 500 Index$2,987S&P Gold Index$750Quarter: S&P / Gold11.7% / -13.4%Mar 31, 2021S&P 500 Index$3,159S&P Gold Index$677Quarter: S&P / Gold5.8% / -9.7%Jun 30, 2021S&P 500 Index$3,417S&P Gold Index$700Quarter: S&P / Gold8.2% / 3.5%Sep 30, 2021S&P 500 Index$3,425S&P Gold Index$627Quarter: S&P / Gold0.2% / -10.5%Dec 31, 2021S&P 500 Index$3,790S&P Gold Index$694Quarter: S&P / Gold10.6% / 10.7%Mar 31, 2022S&P 500 Index$3,602S&P Gold Index$829Quarter: S&P / Gold-4.9% / 19.5%Jun 30, 2022S&P 500 Index$3,010S&P Gold Index$623Quarter: S&P / Gold-16.4% / -24.8%Sep 30, 2022S&P 500 Index$2,851S&P Gold Index$575Quarter: S&P / Gold-5.3% / -7.8%Dec 30, 2022S&P 500 Index$3,053S&P Gold Index$660Quarter: S&P / Gold7.1% / 14.9%Mar 31, 2023S&P 500 Index$3,267S&P Gold Index$731Quarter: S&P / Gold7.0% / 10.7%Jun 30, 2023S&P 500 Index$3,539S&P Gold Index$663Quarter: S&P / Gold8.3% / -9.4%Sep 29, 2023S&P 500 Index$3,410S&P Gold Index$600Quarter: S&P / Gold-3.6% / -9.4%Dec 29, 2023S&P 500 Index$3,793S&P Gold Index$675Quarter: S&P / Gold11.2% / 12.5%Mar 28, 2024S&P 500 Index$4,178S&P Gold Index$690Quarter: S&P / Gold10.2% / 2.2%Jun 28, 2024S&P 500 Index$4,342S&P Gold Index$753Quarter: S&P / Gold3.9% / 9.1%Sep 30, 2024S&P 500 Index$4,582S&P Gold Index$876Quarter: S&P / Gold5.5% / 16.3%Dec 31, 2024S&P 500 Index$4,677S&P Gold Index$801Quarter: S&P / Gold2.1% / -8.6%Mar 31, 2025S&P 500 Index$4,462S&P Gold Index$1,088Quarter: S&P / Gold-4.6% / 35.9%Jun 30, 2025S&P 500 Index$4,934S&P Gold Index$1,178Quarter: S&P / Gold10.6% / 8.2%Sep 30, 2025S&P 500 Index$5,318S&P Gold Index$1,742Quarter: S&P / Gold7.8% / 47.9%Dec 31, 2025S&P 500 Index$5,443S&P Gold Index$1,943Quarter: S&P / Gold2.3% / 11.6%Jan 31, 2026S&P 500 Index$5,549S&P Gold Index$2,516Quarter: S&P / Gold1.9% / 29.5%
2011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026

Hover or tap the chart to explore the data

When evaluating the role of an asset class within a portfolio, correlation factors may be simple, but one of the most critical metrics to analyze, particularly in fickle market enviornments like today.

Gold has exhibited a steady, linear increase in 'Beta', gradually moving away from what would traditionally be classified as effective diversification. Instead, the data increasingly reflects equity-like characteristics. This evolution is consistent with other observed dynamics, including +/- 100-300 basis-point intraday volatility, episodic periods of exuberance, and the 'hail mary' increase in ADTV.

Exhibit 2 highlights this shift clearly, showing Gold’s beta to the S&P 500 rising to approximately 0.8, compared to a notable lower historical average of roughly 0.2 over the prior decade - a period that, for the purposes of this note, helps define Gold’s role as a diversifying asset for the past ten years, and in reality, much longer.

Correlation (Beta) of Gold Index has increasingly resembled growth equities, behaving less like an Alternative asset class

Exhibit 2
  • S&P Gold Index Beta to SPX
  • SPX Benchmark
-1.0-0.50.00.51.01.52.02.53.0
Gold’s Beta to S&P 500 has risen materially since COVID, increasing to ~0.8 from ~0.2 over the preceding 10 years.
Dec 31, 2013Gold beta to SPX-0.35SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2014Gold beta to SPX-0.43SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2014Gold beta to SPX-0.43SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2014Gold beta to SPX0.06SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2014Gold beta to SPX0.15SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2015Gold beta to SPX0.00SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2015Gold beta to SPX-0.24SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2015Gold beta to SPX0.10SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2015Gold beta to SPX0.16SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2016Gold beta to SPX-0.24SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2016Gold beta to SPX-0.30SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2016Gold beta to SPX-0.17SPX benchmark1.00Dec 30, 2016Gold beta to SPX-0.04SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2017Gold beta to SPX0.17SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2017Gold beta to SPX0.01SPX benchmark1.00Sep 29, 2017Gold beta to SPX-0.15SPX benchmark1.00Dec 29, 2017Gold beta to SPX-0.33SPX benchmark1.00Mar 29, 2018Gold beta to SPX0.17SPX benchmark1.00Jun 29, 2018Gold beta to SPX0.12SPX benchmark1.00Sep 28, 2018Gold beta to SPX-0.27SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2018Gold beta to SPX-0.64SPX benchmark1.00Mar 29, 2019Gold beta to SPX-0.43SPX benchmark1.00Jun 28, 2019Gold beta to SPX-0.43SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2019Gold beta to SPX-0.49SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2019Gold beta to SPX-0.33SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2020Gold beta to SPX0.09SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2020Gold beta to SPX0.60SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2020Gold beta to SPX0.45SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2020Gold beta to SPX0.32SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2021Gold beta to SPX0.37SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2021Gold beta to SPX0.42SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2021Gold beta to SPX0.44SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2021Gold beta to SPX0.46SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2022Gold beta to SPX0.34SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2022Gold beta to SPX0.55SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2022Gold beta to SPX0.57SPX benchmark1.00Dec 30, 2022Gold beta to SPX0.61SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2023Gold beta to SPX0.61SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2023Gold beta to SPX0.56SPX benchmark1.00Sep 29, 2023Gold beta to SPX0.65SPX benchmark1.00Dec 29, 2023Gold beta to SPX0.93SPX benchmark1.00Mar 28, 2024Gold beta to SPX0.94SPX benchmark1.00Jun 28, 2024Gold beta to SPX0.94SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2024Gold beta to SPX0.96SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2024Gold beta to SPX0.96SPX benchmark1.00Mar 31, 2025Gold beta to SPX0.87SPX benchmark1.00Jun 30, 2025Gold beta to SPX0.43SPX benchmark1.00Sep 30, 2025Gold beta to SPX0.59SPX benchmark1.00Dec 31, 2025Gold beta to SPX0.78SPX benchmark1.00Jan 31, 2026Gold beta to SPX0.80SPX benchmark1.00
2014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026

Hover or tap the chart to explore the data

This analysis is not a call for or against Gold. Rather, it reflects a recognition that the fundamentals underlying the asset class have changed. Strong performance is not in question; however, greater discipline and clarity are required when determining allocation levels and defining the role an asset is expected to play within a portfolio. In my view, a simple sharpe ratio will dilute the case for Gold.

My core stance is that Gold should no longer be treated as a traditional Alternative asset, but rather tackled as a tactical trade. While the trade may, and likely will, continue to benefit from dollar (USD) uncertainty & supportive structural tailwinds, it should be evaluated with greater discipline and intent. This exposure is best viewed as an allocation characterized by elevated volatility, shifting correlation dynamics, and holds meaningful capacity to either enhance or detract from overall portfolio capital in the near to mid-term.

I recently made a bet with a buddy that Gold finishes within 5% of the S&P 500 by year-end. After a ~15% move this week and ~24% MTD, I’m about ready to concede. The silver lining: he’s a die-hard Broncos fan, I was born and raised in New England, and I’ll happily make that trade for another Super Bowl run. Not that they’re correlated - but I know he’ll be reading this. Go Pats.

Cameron Stanton

Market Note, January 2026

Underlying data, 2010–2026 Show tableHide table
Gold (S&P Global TSX Global Gold Index)
DateNAV @ CloseQuarterly Px2 (%)NAV Growth2Annual Px2 (%)Last 3yr Beta2
31/12/2010420.62-1,000
31/3/2011397.69-5.5%945
30/6/2011365.20-8.2%868
30/9/2011394.898.1%939
30/12/2011360.40-8.7%857-14.3%
30/3/2012336.40-6.7%800
29/6/2012304.33-9.5%724
28/9/2012349.3114.8%830
31/12/2012303.04-13.2%720-15.9%
28/3/2013254.83-15.9%606
28/6/2013170.40-33.1%405
30/9/2013176.053.3%419
31/12/2013156.45-11.1%372-48.4%-0.4
31/3/2014180.8615.6%430-0.4
30/6/2014196.548.7%467-0.4
30/9/2014166.55-15.3%3960.1
31/12/2014145.80-12.5%347-6.8%0.1
31/3/2015156.247.2%3710.0
30/6/2015150.77-3.5%358-0.2
30/9/2015124.16-17.6%2950.1
31/12/2015129.534.3%308-11.2%0.2
31/3/2016182.2340.7%433-0.2
30/6/2016252.6338.6%601-0.3
30/9/2016237.28-6.1%564-0.2
30/12/2016194.25-18.1%46250.0%-0.0
31/3/2017207.606.9%4940.2
30/6/2017194.86-6.1%4630.0
29/9/2017196.230.7%467-0.1
29/12/2017195.46-0.4%4650.6%-0.3
29/3/2018186.58-4.5%4440.2
29/6/2018191.542.7%4550.1
28/9/2018154.59-19.3%368-0.3
31/12/2018186.8020.8%444-4.4%-0.6
29/3/2019195.354.6%464-0.4
28/6/2019220.5012.9%524-0.4
30/9/2019235.586.8%560-0.5
31/12/2019261.3010.9%62139.9%-0.3
31/3/2020235.71-9.8%5600.1
30/6/2020345.9546.8%8220.6
30/9/2020364.295.3%8660.5
31/12/2020315.42-13.4%75020.7%0.3
31/3/2021284.70-9.7%6770.4
30/6/2021294.573.5%7000.4
30/9/2021263.71-10.5%6270.4
31/12/2021291.9910.7%694-7.4%0.5
31/3/2022348.8119.5%8290.3
30/6/2022262.16-24.8%6230.5
30/9/2022241.80-7.8%5750.6
30/12/2022277.7914.9%660-4.9%0.6
31/3/2023307.5710.7%7310.6
30/6/2023278.69-9.4%6630.6
29/9/2023252.38-9.4%6000.6
29/12/2023284.0512.5%6752.3%0.9
28/3/2024290.342.2%6900.9
28/6/2024316.859.1%7530.9
30/9/2024368.6116.3%8761.0
31/12/2024336.92-8.6%80118.6%1.0
31/3/2025457.8035.9%1,0880.9
30/6/2025495.438.2%1,1780.4
30/9/2025732.6247.9%1,7420.6
31/12/2025817.4111.6%1,943142.6%0.8
31/1/20261,058.3529.5%2,516131.2%0.8
S&P 500 (SPX Index)
DateNAV @ CloseQuarterly Px2 (%)NAV Growth2Annual Px2 (%)Last 3yr Beta2
31/12/20101,257.64-1,000
31/3/20111,325.835.4%1,054
30/6/20111,320.64-0.4%1,050
30/9/20111,131.42-14.3%900
30/12/20111,257.6011.2%1,000-0.0%
30/3/20121,408.4712.0%1,120
29/6/20121,362.16-3.3%1,083
28/9/20121,440.675.8%1,146
31/12/20121,426.19-1.0%1,13413.4%
28/3/20131,569.1910.0%1,248
28/6/20131,606.282.4%1,277
30/9/20131,681.554.7%1,337
31/12/20131,848.369.9%1,47029.6%1
31/3/20141,872.341.3%1,4891
30/6/20141,960.234.7%1,5591
30/9/20141,972.290.6%1,5681
31/12/20142,058.904.4%1,63711.4%1
31/3/20152,067.890.4%1,6441
30/6/20152,063.11-0.2%1,6401
30/9/20151,920.03-6.9%1,5271
31/12/20152,043.946.5%1,625-0.7%1
31/3/20162,059.740.8%1,6381
30/6/20162,098.861.9%1,6691
30/9/20162,168.273.3%1,7241
30/12/20162,238.833.3%1,7809.5%1
31/3/20172,362.725.5%1,8791
30/6/20172,423.412.6%1,9271
29/9/20172,519.364.0%2,0031
29/12/20172,673.616.1%2,12619.4%1
29/3/20182,640.87-1.2%2,1001
29/6/20182,718.372.9%2,1611
28/9/20182,913.987.2%2,3171
31/12/20182,506.85-14.0%1,993-6.2%1
29/3/20192,834.4013.1%2,2541
28/6/20192,941.763.8%2,3391
30/9/20192,976.741.2%2,3671
31/12/20193,230.788.5%2,56928.9%1
31/3/20202,584.59-20.0%2,0551
30/6/20203,100.2920.0%2,4651
30/9/20203,363.008.5%2,6741
31/12/20203,756.0711.7%2,98716.3%1
31/3/20213,972.895.8%3,1591
30/6/20214,297.508.2%3,4171
30/9/20214,307.540.2%3,4251
31/12/20214,766.1810.6%3,79026.9%1
31/3/20224,530.41-4.9%3,6021
30/6/20223,785.38-16.4%3,0101
30/9/20223,585.62-5.3%2,8511
30/12/20223,839.507.1%3,053-19.4%1
31/3/20234,109.317.0%3,2671
30/6/20234,450.388.3%3,5391
29/9/20234,288.05-3.6%3,4101
29/12/20234,769.8311.2%3,79324.2%1
28/3/20245,254.3510.2%4,1781
28/6/20245,460.483.9%4,3421
30/9/20245,762.485.5%4,5821
31/12/20245,881.632.1%4,67723.3%1
31/3/20255,611.85-4.6%4,4621
30/6/20256,204.9510.6%4,9341
30/9/20256,688.467.8%5,3181
31/12/20256,845.502.3%5,44316.4%1
31/1/20266,978.031.9%5,54924.3%1

1 Source: All data is sourced from S&P Global Capital IQ. ‘Gold Index’ refers to the S&P Global TSX Global Gold Index, while the ‘S&P 500’ refers to the SPX Index.

2 Analysis: conducted independently and reflects the personal views of the author. Quarterly Px represents the percentage price change over the prior three-month period, while Annual Px represents the percentage price change over the trailing twelve-month period. NAV Growth is rebased to a common starting value to facilitate comparable NAV movements across indexes. 3-Year Beta reflects a rolling 36-month regression slope of the referenced Gold Index relative to the referenced S&P 500 Index.

Market Note.

Written by Cameron Stanton

Questions, ideas or a different view

LinkedIn

Disclaimer. The views expressed on Market Note are solely those of the author in a personal capacity and do not represent the views of any current or former employer, its affiliates, or clients. All content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal, tax or accounting advice, nor a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or financial instrument. Opinions are subject to change without notice, and information is drawn from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy or completeness. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers should consult a qualified professional before making any investment decision.

© 2026 Cameron Stanton. All rights reserved.